Gabarito disponível
Leia o texto para responder às questões de números 53 a 57.
Many assumptions of a communicative orientation towards language teaching need questioning in a global context. Ozóg (1989) discusses the idea of the ‘information gap’, which is supposed to induce students to speak. ‘Are we as Europeans’, he asks, ‘not making a cultural assumption that speakers the world over are uneasy in silence and that they have an overwhelming desire to fill gaps which occur in natural discourse?’ (p.399). Silence is a salient feature of conversation in the Malay world, he points out, a feature that has also been noted in Japan and a number of other cultures.
Indeed, the whole question of requiring others to speak needs to be questioned in terms of both cultural and gender differences. The point here is not to exoticize some notion of cultural difference, but rather to suggest that language is a cultural practice, that both language and thinking about language are always located in very particular social, cultural and political contexts. How language (including silence, paralanguage, and so on) is used, therefore, differs extensively from one context to another, and thus any approach to language teaching based on one particular view of language may be completely inapplicable in another context. If particular language teaching practices (advertised and exported as the best, newest and most scientific) support certain views of language, then such practices clearly present a particular cultural politics and make the English language classroom a site of struggle over different ways of thinking about and dealing with language.
(A. Pennycook, The Cultural Politics of English as an International Language.London and New York: Routledge. 2017. Adaptado)
In the last sentence of the text, the expression “such practices” refers to language teaching practices which reflect
Resolução comentada
'Such practices' retoma as práticas exportadas como as melhores, expressão do poder do conhecimento global.
'Such practices' retoma as práticas de ensino anunciadas e exportadas como as melhores, mais novas e mais científicas, que apoiam certas visões de linguagem. O texto as associa a uma política cultural particular, ou seja, ao poder de um conhecimento globalmente difundido (A).
Análise das alternativas
B) O texto diz 'advertised as' the best; é a propaganda, não uma constatação de que sejam as melhores. C) A disputa é consequência dessas práticas, não aquilo que elas refletem. D) O texto fala em práticas novas e exportadas, não tradicionais. E) Inovação é só uma característica anunciada, e não o que as práticas refletem.
Referência: Pennycook (2017), texto-base.
Resolução comentada do VaiConcursos.